Thursday, November 05, 2009

Mismatch

I was going to write a post about the new sweater I am knitting for NB - MinO- which I have been loving. However, last night as I was working on another project I ran into a problem. So my dear readers you get some of my musings.
First the players:
The Yarn : Louet Gems Sport. 2 skeins of 100g/225 yrds merino, ball band gauge 22-24 sts/4"
The Intended: Christmas present for my SIL
Some background
  1. When I first bought the yarn I was thinking socks
  2. The yarn has been wound in balls for awhile now, since I was always going to cast on for socks with it
  3. My SIL saw the yarn and remarked how lovely the colour is, (I love colour as well)
  4. I cruised Ravelry and decided on Embossed Leaves - people have knit these socks with this yarn
  5. I don't know how the above was accomplished. I need size 2.0 mm(US 0) to get gauge and that hurts my hands. With a 16 st repeat I can't cut out a pattern repeat.
The delimina
  1. The yarn now is saying scarf/shawl to me - do I listen?
  2. Will the recipient wear the red scarf/shawllette? I know she would have worn the socks
  3. Do I knit her socks out of another yarn?
  4. Do I want to knit another red scarf after I just finished Sugared Pompa?
The ideas - feel free to toss others out there (all are Rav links)
  1. Boneyard shawl
  2. Red Skies at Night
  3. Drop Stitch Scarf
  4. Flower Basket Shawl
  5. Herbivore

2 comments:

Sarah said...

I know the yarn you are talking about. I say still socks, different pattern!

Jenni said...

I'd like to second Sarah's comment - make socks, but go for a different pattern.

However, if you are set on a scarf, consider the situations in which the recipient might wear the scarf - the patterns you're considering are very different! Boneyard Shawl, for example, is very simple and understated - could work in a variety of situations. Red skies at night and Flowerbasket are a bit fancier while the drop stitch scarf is very casual. I don't care for herbivore. But if I have to pick, I go for Red skies at night. Fancy enough to keep your interest, appropriate to wear at work or even out to a nice dinner. Smart and stylish.